All American Tree & Turf vs Frascatore Landscaping: which fits a design & installation project?
Both businesses score well on our methodology, but they built their reputations on different work. One is known primarily for tree removal and pruning, the other for full landscape overhauls and plant installation. That distinction matters more than the composite score if you're hiring specifically for design and installation.
The differences that matter
- Core trade focus. All American Tree & Turf's reviews center on tree removal, pruning, and cabling, while Frascatore Landscaping's reviews describe full landscape restorations, plantings, and drainage installs.
- Design and planting knowledge. Frascatore's owner Joe is credited with knowledge of plants, soils, and growing conditions and mentors clients on plant care after install, a skill set not mentioned in All American's record.
- Complexity of installs handled. Frascatore's reviews cite 30-year overgrown plantings, full lawn restorations, French drains, and stump/old shed removal, all installation-adjacent work, whereas All American's scope stays within tree services.
- Aftercare and maintenance. Frascatore runs year-round maintenance contracts and snow plowing alongside installs, while All American's follow-up service isn't described beyond the tree work itself.
- Track record depth. All American has more reviews overall (166 vs 83) and 20+ years in business, but that history is built on tree services rather than design and installation projects.
Side by side
- Google rating
- All American Tree & Turf LLC: 4.9 (166 reviews)
- Frascatore Landscaping LLC: 5 (83 reviews)
- Services
- All American Tree & Turf LLC: lawn care maintenance, landscape design installation, tree service, snow removal
- Frascatore Landscaping LLC: lawn care maintenance, landscape design installation, hardscaping masonry, snow removal
- Specialty fit for design & installation
- All American Tree & Turf LLC: Tree removal, pruning, and cabling; turf care mentioned but design work not described
- Frascatore Landscaping LLC: Full landscape design, plant installation, restorations, and drainage work
- Best suited for
- All American Tree & Turf LLC: Properties needing tree removal or pruning alongside general turf care
- Frascatore Landscaping LLC: Full-property landscape redesigns, overgrown plantings, or drainage and terrain projects
- Post-install support
- All American Tree & Turf LLC: Not mentioned in reviews
- Frascatore Landscaping LLC: Year-round maintenance contracts, snow plowing, and client education on plant care
- Verification
- All American Tree & Turf LLC: Google-verified
- Frascatore Landscaping LLC: Google-verified
- Composite score
- All American Tree & Turf LLC: 90
- Frascatore Landscaping LLC: 90
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
All American Tree & Turf LLC
Edwin's crew handles tree removal with consistent professionalism, arriving on schedule and leaving properties spotless. Over 20 years in business, they work across Stamford, Westport, Fairfield, and surrounding towns with equipment and expertise that meets or exceeds customer expectations.
Repeat clients cite fair pricing, clear communication during estimates and planning, and genuine care for both property and safety. The team works through the full scope of tree services listed on their website, from removal to specialty pruning and cabling. Recent feedback shows no recurring service gaps, though an isolated phone-handling moment early on remains an outlier in their otherwise consistent record.
Frascatore Landscaping LLC
All 20 recent reviews award five stars. Customers consistently praise Joe's communication, responsiveness, and willingness to stay on site until jobs are finished right. The crew handles big landscape overhauls (30-year overgrown plantings, full lawn restorations, root removal) and routine maintenance equally well. Attention to detail and spotless cleanup are recurring notes. No complaints appear in recent reviews.
Joe mentors customers on plant care, watering schedules, and equipment choices after projects wrap. Staff arrive on schedule, work efficiently, and tackle challenging terrain and structures (hills, French drains, stumps, old sheds) without hesitation. The business also provides snow plowing and runs year-round maintenance contracts.
Which should you pick?
Pick All American Tree & Turf LLC if
- Your project is primarily tree removal, pruning, or cabling rather than new plantings or hardscape
- You want the longer track record: 20+ years in business and 166 reviews under owner Edwin
- You need work across Stamford, Westport, Fairfield, and nearby towns with a crew known for clean site handoffs
Pick Frascatore Landscaping LLC if
- You're planning a full landscape design and installation, including new plantings, lawn restoration, or drainage work
- You want the owner (Joe) personally on site through the project, with guidance on plant care and watering after install
- You need work on difficult terrain (hills, old stumps, sheds) as part of the install
- You want a business that also handles year-round maintenance after the installation is complete
Verdict
Frascatore Landscaping fits the design and installation job better, based on a review record built around full restorations, plantings, and drainage installs, plus an owner credited with plant and soil knowledge. All American Tree & Turf is the stronger pick if tree removal or pruning is the actual scope of work, since that's where its 20+ year track record and higher review volume are concentrated, but it's a less direct match for a design-and-install project specifically.
Can't decide which fits your needs?
Tell us what you need and compare quotes from landscaper in Connecticut.
When you submit a quote or contact form on this site, your enquiry may be shared with partner providers who can do the work. We may earn a referral fee, but our rankings and scores are based solely on our published scoring method and are never influenced by referral fees.
Common questions
- Which business is better for a full yard redesign with new plantings?
- Frascatore Landscaping, based on reviews describing full lawn restorations, overgrown plantings, and drainage work like French drains.
- What if my project mainly involves removing trees before landscaping?
- All American Tree & Turf's reviews center on tree removal, pruning, and cabling with 20+ years of experience in that specific trade.
- Does either company help with care after installation?
- Frascatore's reviews mention year-round maintenance contracts, snow plowing, and the owner educating clients on plant care and watering after a project wraps. That kind of aftercare isn't described in All American's reviews.
- How do their review numbers compare?
- All American Tree & Turf has a 4.9 rating from 166 reviews. Frascatore Landscaping has a 5.0 rating from 83 reviews, with no complaints noted in recent reviews.